Phish - 1987

ATO Fraternity House, St. Lawrence University
Canton, NY, United States map

Set List

Sound Check

Set I

Set II


Show Notes

This show was a pledge party that took place in the basement of the ATO House. This setlist was adopted from fan sources as there are no tapes in the archives. As a result, the sets as listed may be incomplete or incorrect, ie: it’s possible what is listed as set III was actually the end of set II. This show featured the 1st known performances of Phase Dance (Pat Metheny cover) and I Didn’t Know (Richard “Nancy” Wright cover). The soundcheck and what is listed here as set III were adpoted from the circulating source at The online account by provides good context about this early gig. To summarize, ATO at the time was a Deadhead-centric, music friendly fraternity and Scott was in attendance. He recounted that the band provided a soundboard patch to a fraternity member and that some people had to leave the room for sanity’s sake during Whipping Post. As was often true, Trey’s dog Marley attended this show. Peaches en Regalia was played by request. After Possum, somebody said “Congratulations to New pledges. I hope everyone is feeling most Irie.” Trey added “someone requested a Pat Metheny song, so we’re going to do a Pat Metheny Song” to which an audience member yelled “Play Phase Dance.” After Phase Dance, Trey said “now we’d like to play one by another of our favorite bands” as they started Good Times Bad Times. Some circulating copies of this show are incomplete and out of order and some are mislabeled “Pledge Party, Burlington, VT”.